Tests and Teacher Pay

An issue brief from the Century Foundation by Gordon MacInnes: “Eight Reasons Not to Tie Teacher Pay to Student Test Scores.”

Reason #1: Tying test scores to teacher compensation suggests that teachers are holding back on using their experience, expertise, and time because they are not being paid for the extra effort.

Reason # 2: The standardized tests in most states are lousy and so are the standards they are designed to measure.

Reason #3: The idea of compensating teachers individually in order to differentiate their performance from their school colleagues defeats a principal tenet of good instruction—that teachers need to learn from one another to solve difficult pedagogical challenges.

Reason #4: Most teachers do not teach a grade or subject that is subject to standardized testing.

Reason # 5: Even reliable standardized tests are valid only when they are used for their intended purposes.

Reason #6: A key assumption of using test scores to judge teachers is that students are randomly assigned, first, to schools, and, second, to classes. Neither is true.

Reason #7: State data systems are in their infancy. It turns out that it is harder, is more expensive, and takes longer for states to produce reliable, accurate, and secure longitudinal data on students and teachers than widely assumed.

Reason #8: The rationale for tying tests to compensation is not clear.  …  if teacher compensation does not keep up with inflation because of poor student performance, then teachers will . . . what? Work harder? Dig deeper? Stay longer? There is no evidence that such measures improve instructional practices or student outcomes.

And as Diane Ravitch points out: to tie test scores to teacher evaluation requires a minimum of three years’ data. At then end … what? Fire the “bad” teachers? And replace them with … who? new teachers? There is no precedent for this in any other developing nation.

Read MacInnes’ entire brief here.

Recently found … 11/03/2009

  • The Federal Government produces an immeasurable amount of data each day. DataMasher helps citizens have a little fun with those data by creating mashups to visualize them in different ways and see how states compare on important issues. Users can combine different data sets in interesting ways and create their own custom rankings of the states.

    tags: data, mashup, visualization, statistics, maps, tools

  • “Free Online OCR service allows you to …
    -Recognize text and characters from PDF scanned documents (including multipage files), photographs and digital camera captured images. Service allows users to select 28 languages to recognize multilingual documents.
    -Convert OCR results directly to your favorite formats including Adobe PDF, Microsoft Word, Microsoft Excel, Rtf, Html and Txt. Converted documents look exactly like the original – tables, columns, bullets and graphics.
    -Store OCRed files online in your secure workspace. Also you can download these files on your PC, edit text and print.”

    tags: ocr, tools, pdf, convert, online

Posted from Diigo. The rest of my favorite links are here.